Home - Home and Auto Insurance

H O M E & A U T O I N S U R A N C E

The things that matter to you, matter to us.

START A CUSTOM QUOTE CONTACT AN AGENT BUNDLE AND SAVE

BUNDLE & SAVE

Learn More

NEXT-00641_NeFa_2023_54_Digital_Promo_Kit_WINNERS_June28

Carolina Property Insurance

4.9

Based on 156 reviews

review us on

Corey Ingle

19:42 15 Nov 24

Excellent service. Had quotes over very quickly and helped us out through the whole process. Other companies never even called back.

lj noble

16:20 11 Nov 24

Micah Witherspoon is one of the most professional people I have ever dealt with. He was knowledgeable, courteous and was always available for any questions.

Olga Grabau

14:53 05 Nov 24

My husband and I started our relationship with Carolina Property Insurance before we moved to Myrtle Beach through telephone and email conversations. We cannot be more satisfied with their professional and efficient customer service. Everyone at the agency is a pleasure to do business with. Without reservation, we recommend Carolina Property Insurance.

Peter Fiscina

13:43 05 Nov 24

Carolina Property Insurance has been great with me insuring my beach house going above and beyond expectations.

stacey bishop

16:59 28 Oct 24

Nick was extremely helpful, polite and eager to help me figure out my issue. He gave me his contact details so I could get back with him personally if needed and to help expedite the process my end.

Cindy Thomas

16:07 18 Oct 24

Allison Shaw was a pleasure to work with during our homeowner insurance search. She was personable and knowledgeable. Due to her due diligence, we decided to purchase our insurance with her.

Leticia Remauro

15:22 10 Oct 24

We had a great experience with Carolina Property Insurance. Our agent, Micah Whiterspoon was knowledgeable, courteous and attentive. The policies he wrote were exactly what we needed and a great value.

William

10:32 10 Oct 24

Gina was very timely, professional and complete in providing information for our renewal of homeowner insurance. We are reviewing the current provider and expecting more information on other providers from Gina.

Stephen Paglieroni

17:08 09 Oct 24

Was referred to Carolina property insurance by a customer of mine and was treated excellent and received an awesome deal.
Thank you Gina

Allen Nathan

12:36 04 Oct 24

What can i say ? So happy i found Gina and Carolina PropertyI insurance. Not only was the price better than most, But the Service was second to no one. Very responsive to questions and extremely helpful.

Brad Simonis

14:03 26 Sep 24

Great service and pricing.

Richard Ressler

18:43 25 Sep 24

I contacted Allison for homeowners insurance, she made it easy and contacted my lender for me. Thanks Allison.

Lawrence Estep

17:13 25 Sep 24

Great service!!

Deborah Shine

11:52 25 Sep 24

Thank you, Gina Vatell, for your prompt, professional, personal service! I highly recommend Gina and Carolina Property Insurance for your insurance needs. Gina patiently shopped numerous carriers to secure the best coverage and price. She truly cares about her clients. Contact her for your next quote.

Tana Kohlbus

20:47 24 Sep 24

Okay, experience today but I must add working with Nick was perfect. He was very helpful and so patient with me because I ask a lot of questions!! Would highly recommend him and the company he represents.

Manilyn Glemer

18:53 24 Sep 24

Allison was great! She got back to me right away with my question and provided several quotes, making sure I found the best deal from different carriers. I really appreciated her help!

Linda Darrer

20:30 23 Sep 24

Allison Shaw has got to be the best insurance agent I have ever dealt with! She is quick, accurate, assertive and extremely proactive with all my insurance needs getting me the best coverage along with the best quotes for lower premiums than what I had been paying. It's definitely less stressful getting all your policies thru one agency and I highly recommend Carolina Property Insurance.

17:14 18 Sep 24

19:42 17 Sep 24

00:09 17 Sep 24

12:43 13 Sep 24

Thank You for your response. Feel better
Loretta

Joan Simons

15:06 12 Sep 24

lasziz zalik

18:48 10 Sep 24

Tiffany Plemmons

15:30 09 Sep 24

Micah was great to work with on insuring our new home. He was through, looked for the best options, and provided a great experience. Thank you again!

Pat Mullaney

18:20 05 Sep 24

Efficient and easy

Michelle Allen

13:01 05 Sep 24

I really apricate how helpful my agent Alison is and is very nice to work with...

Kenneth Smith

14:05 02 Sep 24

cristina constantin

14:42 28 Aug 24

An excellent experience. Great Customer Care skills, clarity and professionalism. Thank you!

Cindy Paglia

15:51 26 Aug 24

Michael was great! He was extremely knowledable, helpful and patient

Melissa Paré

15:49 26 Aug 24

Micah was super helpful and found me a competitive rate for home owner's insurance. Where I live isn't easy to find an insurance company to cover our home so it was nice to find someone so helpful. He communicated with me throughout the process and was accommodating when I had to make adjustments to our meeting times. I highly recommend Carolina Property Insurance and Micah as an agent, it was a pleasure doing business with them.

Gladys Perez

18:16 15 Aug 24

Nick had been very helpful and was very professional with me. He helped me quickly!

Marlene Levin

18:52 12 Aug 24

Nicholas Arditi is a very knowledgeable individual. He has been most helpful to us in our dealings with him. We would recommend him to anyone who is looking for homeowners or auto insurance. Also he is a very nice person in general. He will always return a call or look up information that you have requested. We are very satisfied with his service. Marlene & Bill Levin

Phyllis Pagliaro

21:17 08 Aug 24

Nathan Harris

00:34 27 Jan 24

Very quick turn around time for a quote. Easy to work with and very responsive.

Rayann Maxey

20:32 26 Jan 24

Micah was very knowledgeable and courteous.in helping us through the process.

John Maloney

20:01 23 Jan 24

Friendly, knowledgeable and helpful service. Allison took her time with us and fully explained our new policies.

Alyssa

17:57 23 Jan 24

Jim Folz

14:38 23 Jan 24

Excellent service from Allison. Fast and easy quote at a reasonable price. I am looking forward to working with her on my vehicle needs soon.

Monique Baril

12:16 13 Dec 23

We were referred to this company by friends, as we are out of state and were on a time crunch I wasn’t sure what to expect. No worries Allison took very good care of us. She answered my questions and is very pleasant to work with.

Jon Basty

17:45 29 Nov 23

My Wife and I are relocating to South Carolina. We reached out to Carolina Property Insurance requesting a quote for homeowners insurance. Our agent , Allison Shaw , was very helpful. Allison provided us with a quote and answered our questions. Allison has been a pleasure to deal with. I would highly recommend Carolina Property Insurance and our agent , Allison Shaw to anyone in the market for insurance

Anthony Jacobo

01:41 21 Nov 23

Great new customer experience from quote to purchase! Had a short timeframe needs and Micah was topnotch. Had knowledgeable answers for all the questions I had and remained super helpful through the process. Gonna recommend Carolina Property Insurance to everybody moving forward. Thank you Micah!

Brenda Hembree

15:44 18 Sep 23

Allison at Carolina Property Insurance was wonderful to work with. Insurance in the MB area is expensive, but we received the best coverage through Carolina PI. Additionally, she was responsive to messages and a pleasure to work with.

HOMEOWNERS

CONDO OWNERS

RENTERS

FLOOD INSURANCE

AUTO

MOTORCYCLE

BOAT/WATERCRAFT

BUNDLE & SAVE

3 Myths About Owning A Condo

Renting Advice

Hurricane Safety